Don't Give Caesar the Power of Your Imagination

Sermon Delivered to Lake Avenue Baptist Church, Rochester

Matthew 22: 15-22

15Then the Pharisees went and plotted to entrap him in what he said. 16So they sent their disciples to him, along with the Herodians, saying, “Teacher, we know that you are sincere, and teach the way of God in accordance with truth, and show deference to no one; for you do not regard people with partiality. 17Tell us, then, what you think. Is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, or not?” 18But Jesus, aware of their malice, said, “Why are you putting me to the test, you hypocrites? 19Show me the coin used for the tax.” And they brought him a denarius. 20Then he said to them, “Whose head is this, and whose title?” 21They answered, “The emperor’s.” Then he said to them, “Give therefore to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” 22When they heard this, they were amazed; and they left him and went away.

Trapped Between Empire and God

For me, Matthew 22 is one of those defining texts of Jesus’s ministry, and it’s a text that I’ve wrestled with quite a bit in my life, so it was a blessing to have this be today’s lectionary passage when I was invited to preach.

For context, it's important to remember that the Jewish people were living under Roman occupation at the time. Jesus, this new Jewish teacher, is regarded with deep suspicion by the authorities of his time. Both those from among his people who supported the Roman occupation, the Herodians and those who were critical of it, the Pharisees, were suspicious of him. They are trying to trap Jesus, and their alliance is unexpected.

Professor of New Testament at Virginia Union, Yunk Su Kim explains: “They are confident that this question will trouble and alienate him because he would find it difficult to answer either way. A simple ‘yes’ seemingly contradicts his general teaching about God since true loyalty is rendered to God only. A dauntless ‘no’ will make him an anti-imperial radical revolutionary. They expected Jesus to choose an ‘all-or-nothing’ position whose logic is ‘If you give everything to God, there is nothing you can spare to give to Caesar, or vice versa.’”

The New Testament scholar Chelsea Harmon argues, “No good believer can argue with the fact that God is God of all. From the time in the desert as the people of God were being regathered and reoriented, they have been enculturated in a spirituality where God is at the center, where their whole selves—body, soul, mind, and spirit—have been dedicated and anointed to the Lord. There is no question: we might belong to other allegiances here on earth, but ultimately, we belong to and bear the mark of the Creator.”

This text has mattered a lot to me in my life. As a Baptist who clings to my Anabaptist roots, it reinforces the absence of flags in our sanctuaries, the separation of church and state and our fight for the religious liberties that we hold dear. It has also animated my convictions around my obligation to conscience and not the state in matters of peace and war. 

Now, this is still the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, and we are in Rochester, where Frederick Douglass lived and agitated for abolition for much of his life. Yesterday, Rick took me to Douglass’s grave for me to express gratitude for his life. 

I have no doubt that here in Rochester many of you have read Douglass’s  “What to the Slave is the Fourth of July.” I’m sure it’s been very present this year. You will understand then that as a descendant of the enslaved, I was born into a peculiar relationship to my country. I was born into a peculiar relationship to the Western World.

In order for this next bit of wrestling with the text to make any sense, I need to situate you in some details of my biography.

I am in some ways a child of NATO. Born in Germany, to parents serving their country, I have now spent half my life in Europe and half my life in the United States. The liberal order that emerged after World War II has shaped my biography in intimate ways. Although I hold dear to my African roots, I am unmistakably a product of the West.

I am also a gay man, and I am shaped by the fact that we emerged from concentration camps of Europe to a world not proud to have liberated us, but to an “alliance” still criminalizing, beating, and murdering us until only very recently. We have rights in much of Europe and the U.S., but we suffer still. And now, that queer people find our freedoms in the “West,” we are often scapegoated as symbols of western imperialism and subjected to persecution and death in cruel, misguided acts of defiance from the downtrodden in countries still reeling from the ravages of colonialism.

What does the 4th of July mean to me? What allegiance do I owe the United States? Europe? In a post world war liberal order, once again under siege by the return of fascism?

Are unarmed black men, women, my brothers, sisters, and kin of all genders not still brutalized and murdered by police: In every American city, in Rotterdam, The Netherlands  just weeks ago, in Paris, and London?

What do I owe Caesar?

I became a pacifist, a position born out of my faith and my wrestling with the teachings of Jesus. I cannot bring myself to justify killing another soul that so clearly bears the image of God. I lead the International Fellowship of Reconciliation as we defended the right to conscientious objection to military service. I saw through work with nonviolent activists around the world that I am not alone in my convictions, praise God, and I am grateful for that. There are others whose courage shows me the way. 

But I feel the pull of a contemporary trap. Today’s Herodians want me to understand that for all our failures, there is no point in recorded history where someone like me has had it better.

The Herodians of our time will point out the threats of China and Russia. I have no reason to trust these states. They offer me no clearer path to freedom. I concede there is a world of violent struggle around us.

What we must resist

Maybe Jesus was telling us that we have to deal with the world that is. He understood that his people were in a tough place. There was growing discontent about the Roman occupation, there were many who wanted him to lead a violent rebellion; many were prepared to follow him in that fight. He must have understood the lives that rebellion would cost. That was not going to be his way. As unsatisfying as his message might have felt at that time, I think he was trying to point us to something more powerful, something that outlasts empires. “I will lift mine eyes to hills from whence commeth my help” I often heard my elders say as a kid. They would quote that first verse of Psalm 121 in difficult times. They were reminding me then what I think Jesus reminds us here also: Our deliverance comes from God. 

Just because this is how things are, don’t you for one second believe that this is how they must be, that this how they should be! That this is the will of God, don’t stop imagining another world, don’t concede your hope, don’t give that to Caesar.

My friend, Krista Tippett, when reflecting on her experiences in divided Berlin, has often reflected on the fact that “whenever massive historical shifts occur, the new world that arrives often looks entirely unlike what anyone could have predicted or planned for. It is a world that was unimaginable except for very few.”

So, my dear brothers and sisters, my dear kin of every gender. Today’s Herodians want us to accept a perversity of logic that would have us settle for murderous regimes and genocidal conquests. They would paint a picture of a world that would necessitate the trampling of civil liberties, and the denial of our hard-won freedoms. They would have us accept a world where there’s not enough money to feed the hungry but where there is enough to advance new high-tech weaponry that miscalculates and murders schools full of children.

They tell us, these are the options we have in our violent circumstances, choices between violence and more violence, war and no war. When there seems to be no constraint to their innovation in the service of greed. They say, this is the most we can hope for. I say No, Caesar, no.

Now, I know that I’m delivering this sermon just over a week before midterm elections, so please let me be clear. I will vote what my conscience will allow. I will participate in the beleaguered and failing democracy that we have only just begun. One of my teachers and mentors Vincent Harding used to often say that “when it comes to being a multicultural, multi racial democracy, the United States is still a developing country.”

I will give to Caesar what is Caesar’s as I struggle against the evils the empire has wrought, but it will not possess my faith, it will not let it limit my imagination, it will not lay claim to my soul. It will not limit my capacity to resist and to demand more of us, to demand more for us. I have no other choice. Not just because the status quo is untenable for a person in my body in this moment of history, but because my life belongs to God. 

The good news is however, that God can accomplish things that empires cannot even imagine.